Explore the shared perspective of philosophers David Hume and Thomas Reid on testimony. Learn why both emphasize the importance of discerning trustworthy sources in belief formation.
Question
What do both Hume and Reid agree on regarding testimony?
A. Testimony should always be accepted without question.
B. Testimony should be the sole basis of all beliefs.
C. Testimony is an unreliable source of knowledge.
D. Good believers learn to be discriminating about the testimony they trust.
Answer
D. Good believers learn to be discriminating about the testimony they trust.
Explanation
David Hume and Thomas Reid, despite their differing epistemological approaches to testimony, converge on the idea that individuals must exercise discernment in trusting testimony. Both philosophers recognize that while testimony is a significant source of knowledge, not all testimony is reliable, and thus, critical evaluation is necessary.
Hume’s View
Hume adopts a reductionist stance, arguing that testimonial knowledge is justified only if it is supported by other sources, such as perception or memory. He emphasizes that trust in testimony should be based on prior experience with the reliability of the speaker or similar instances of truthfulness. This approach inherently requires discrimination in accepting testimony.
Reid’s View
Reid, a non-reductionist, asserts that humans are naturally inclined to trust testimony due to innate principles like veracity (a tendency to speak truth) and credulity (a disposition to believe others). However, he acknowledges that this natural credulity must be tempered by experience as individuals grow and encounter instances of deceit or falsehood. Thus, Reid also advocates for learning to discern trustworthy sources over time.
Agreement Between Hume and Reid
Both philosophers agree that blind acceptance of testimony is imprudent. They stress the importance of evaluating the credibility of sources and being selective about which testimonies to trust. This shared emphasis aligns with Option D, highlighting the role of intellectual autonomy in navigating testimonial knowledge effectively.
Intellectual Autonomy certification exam assessment practice question and answer (Q&A) dump including multiple choice questions (MCQ) and objective type questions, with detail explanation and reference available free, helpful to pass the Intellectual Autonomy exam and earn Intellectual Autonomy certification.