Want higher open and click-through rates? No matter what type of emails you send, all senders have the same goal: getting to the inbox. This is where deliverability comes in. Now more than ever, we rely on digital means and email to communicate with the world around us. As companies grow and become more ingrained in the lives of their customers, email continues to be the backbone of customer communications. Can you imagine Spotify, Uber, eBay, Airbnb, or any other web application functioning without email?
No? We couldn’t either! This article is full of the latest tips and tricks to help you land in the inbox.
What Is Email Deliverability?
Sender Reputation Breakdown
How to Maintain Your Reputation and Keep Your Recipients Happy
Hyperfocus on User Experience in 2021
Infrastructure and Authentication
Privacy & Compliance in a World of Engagement
SMS: A Complementary Channel of Communication
Email Deliverability Tools
After nearly 50 years, email is still alive and thriving. Email returns the highest ROI of any marketing communications channel, to the tune of $42 returned for every dollar spent. From Baby Boomers to Gen Z, folks continue to choose email to communicate with brands and businesses.
Email is not a set-it-and-forget-it solution. While powerful, it requires maintenance.
Email deliverability is constantly shifting and adapting, which means you’ll need to regularly work at it to stay in the inbox. That’s why we update and release a new version of this guide every year.
Deliverability doesn’t have to be ambiguous and unknown—it’s more straightforward than you might think!
We all want legitimate messages to arrive in the right inboxes at the right time, but ESPs aren’t solely responsible for email deliverability. Getting to the inbox is the responsibility of the sender. We can help you get there.
What Is Email Deliverability?
Email deliverability is the process of sending emails that arrive in your recipient’s inbox as intended. Get your deliverability right, and your messages will arrive in the inbox when and how you expect. Get it wrong, and your message could be routed to the spam folder or completely blocked by the inbox provider.
What’s an Inbox Provider?
Common inbox providers include Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, and Hotmail. These providers offer users a secure place to engage with email by scanning the messages’ content to filter spam and prevent phishing and other unwanted emails.
To maintain consistent delivery rates, businesses need to constantly prioritize the health of their email program. This means properly establishing your infrastructure and authentication, maintaining a positive sending reputation, creating a great user experience, and adapting your program to meet new and changing regulations.
Unfortunately, most businesses only get serious about deliverability after they experience a major issue—once the damage is already done. With the right expert solutions, your deliverability issues can be fixed, but you and your recipients should focus on prevention rather than a cure.
Deliverability isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s a need-to-have. Email returns an average of $42 for every dollar invested (the highest of any digital marketing channel), but that’s not even the most valuable part. Think about the critical emails your customers need to receive:
- Password resets
- Shipping notifications
If these emails don’t arrive, you’re not only losing sales. You’re losing trust. You’re losing loyalty. And you’re eventually losing customers and subscribers.
Deliverability and ROI aren’t some distantly connected concepts—they have an undeniable fiscal relationship. Even tiny improvements in deliverability can make a big impact on the success of your email program. Improving your inbox rate by just 1% means more customers are seeing your emails and can take action on them, leading to increased opens, clicks, and conversions.
Getting into the inbox takes time and energy, but the struggle is worth it.
“As more and more mailbox providers implement machine learning technologies in their fight against spam, making sense of email deliverability will be more critical for senders. While these filtering systems are already very impressive in their accuracy, I predict they will get even more accurate from here. This means that senders will need to devote more thought and resources into what the signals from their email campaigns are really telling them.
Email is all about nurturing relationships. This can’t be done from the spam folder. Investing in deliverability is investing in the quality of your brand’s connection with your customers–and will pay off in more than just improved open rates.”
Sender Reputation Breakdown
Your email deliverability is largely determined by your sender’s reputation. The better your reputation, the more likely your email will be delivered to your recipient’s inbox. Your sender reputation is determined by a wide variety of factors:
- Recipient engagement
- Email content
- Spam complaints
- Spam traps
- Invalid email addresses
- Domain reputation
Your sender reputation (like any great brand or personal reputation) is hard to earn, easy to lose, and takes time to build. It’s established by recipient engagement, email list hygiene, and other emails best practices.
While several factors contribute to how inbox providers evaluate senders, the most important component to prioritize is recipient engagement—how your recipients are interacting with your emails. When your recipients are opening, reading, and clicking on your messages, inbox providers know that your messages are wanted.
It’s important to pay close attention to recipient email engagement. Opens, clicks, unsubscribes, and spam reports are all ways your recipients engage with your messages, but there are other types of positive and negative engagement that are harder to track. Depending on the inbox provider, they might track how many times a message is:
- Deleted without being opened
- Moved to another folder
Inbox providers use all these signals to evaluate every email campaign you send. You won’t know for certain which elements carry the most weight and which new engagement cues they’re taking into consideration (which is why we publish this deliverability guide every year).
For example, if your email campaigns are getting very low open rates, inbox providers may start filtering your future emails to spam because your recipients indicate that the email is unwanted. Or, if you’re getting high unsubscribe rates, inbox providers might read this as another signal that you’re sending unwanted mail.
The Upside to Unsubscribes
Don’t take unsubscribes personally. Sending to an unengaged audience hurts your sending reputation, so your recipient is doing you a favor by unsubscribing instead of ignoring your messages or marking them as spam.
Content includes the words, images, GIFs, templates, links, preheader text, subject lines, and addresses you use in your emails. All of your email’s content either helps or hurts your reputation. To build a good reputation, you’ll need to send engaging emails that have a professional look and legitimate links.
A recipient marking your email as spam is the strongest negative signal to inbox providers. Spam complaint rates above 0.2% are considered high, and these levels can lead to poor deliverability. Some inbox providers consider spam rates even lower than .2% as high, which is why you should always keep a close eye on your spam complaints after each campaign.
Learning to listen to rather than fight against spam complaints is a key skill of advanced email programs.
Spam traps are old or unused email addresses that should never receive your emails. ISPs and anti-spam organizations also plant email addresses to catch spammers and list buyers. These could be email addresses that never signed up to receive communications (AKA recycled spam traps) or emails that haven’t been used recently (AKA pristine spam traps or honeypots, nicknamed by AOL), but each pose a threat to your sending reputation.
The presence of any of these types of addresses in your contact list is a sign that your list is not well-maintained. Avoid these spam traps by removing recipients that no longer engage with your emails or have gone long periods without engagement.
It’s important to avoid purchasing, renting, or scraping email addresses, as those recipients did not sign up to receive your content and will likely provide little to no engagement. There are several ways to build a healthy, engaged contact list no matter the size or scale of your email program.
What Is List Scraping?
List scraping or list harvesting is the process of using software or bot to crawl through different websites and find email addresses that can be added to your contact list. The problem with this strategy is that they (and their respective recipients) have no relationship with you or your company; this means that you shouldn’t be sending them any email.
Only send your emails to people who have indicated an interest in your product or service, or have asked for your emails outright. Otherwise, you’re at risk for spam complaints and a damaged sender reputation.
Invalid Email Addresses
Continuing to send emails to large groups of invalid or nonexistent email addresses is a big red flag for inbox providers and can damage your sending reputation. Reduce the number of emails sent to invalid addresses by immediately cleaning bounced email addresses from your active mailing address.
Build Your Email List from the Ground Up
Leverage other digital channels to build your email list rather than sending unsolicited emails that could damage your reputation. Channels like display ads reach new potential subscribers that may be interested in signing up for your communications.
Targeted display ads can drive interested parties to a landing page where you can explain the benefits of receiving your emails and collect their permission to send to them. Make the email process clear to the recipient everywhere you can. Selling the real value of the emails you send will help to build an engaged email list.
Abandoned email accounts can become invalid addresses, so removing long-term, non-engaged addresses from your list is a great habit. You can also gauge the use and validity of an email address by looking at a recipient’s engagement with welcome emails.
“One of the things I have to work on most often with my clients is updating their list acquisition methods,”
“Rather than bringing over an old list, buying a list from someone, or scraping email addresses of social networks, senders need to create opportunities for people to provide their email addresses…legitimately.”
Avoid “Typo” Traps
Recently, we’ve seen “typo” traps become very common among senders. Avoid this trap by making sure your address collection methodology removes typos in email addresses (e.G. Local@gmall.Com vs. Local@gmail.Com) and double-checking that recipients interact with an opt-in or subsequent welcome message before including their address in email campaigns.
Sending Confirmation Emails
The easiest way to avoid adding invalid addresses and spam traps to your lists or getting included on blacklists is to send confirmation emails to new recipients. This process validates their email and confirms that they want your messages. We cannot stress enough how problematic it is to rent, purchase, or scrape email addresses and how damaging that practice can be to a sending reputation.
Many inbox providers monitor blacklists to help determine which senders need to be blocked or filtered. Most blacklists will list your IP address or sending domain if they notice a high number of spam trap hits, spam or junk complaints, or a combination of both. You can avoid blacklists by sending relevant content to the recipients that have recently engaged with your emails.
Just because you’re on a blacklist doesn’t necessarily mean that your deliverability will suffer. Some blacklists have a much greater impact on deliverability than others.
Not all blacklists are created equal. Some are more prominent than others and may have more impact on your sending reputation if you get listed. Keep in mind that some blacklists have moved to a pay-to-play model, wanting senders to pay to get delisted rather than prove their reliability as a sender.
Your sending domain has a reputation associated with it, and it’s equally as important as your IP address’s reputation. If messages sent from your domain generate a negative response from recipients, it won’t matter what IP addresses the messages come from—they may still be filtered by inbox providers.
Watch your links to third parties—they could do more harm than good. Even if you’re doing everything else right, a single link to an unreputable website in the body of your email could prevent your message from getting to the inbox. Be sure you’re only linking to trusted websites and sources and, ideally, only those that you control.
Cousin domains are triggers for inbox providers. For example, let’s say that company.Com also uses company-mail.Com, companymail.Com, and companydeals.Com to segment different email streams. Those extra domains could impact your deliverability.
Gmail’s Email Address Prefix Preference
“Gmail continues to recommend that senders avoid mixing different types of content (marketing and transactional) in the same message. Gmail is encouraging the use of a different “from: header” based on the category or type of message, which is not a tactic that was previously publicized. For example:
- Purchase receipt messages: firstname.lastname@example.org
- Promotional messages: email@example.com
- Account notification messages: firstname.lastname@example.org
This just yet another layer of Gmail’s filtering.”
All unsubscribe hurt your sending reputation, so avoid them at all costs.
Unsubscribes can actually improve your email deliverability. Sending to an unengaged audience hurts your sending reputation, so your recipient is doing you a favor by unsubscribing instead of ignoring your messages or marking them as spam.
Sending to invalid or nonexistent email addresses hurts your sending reputation.
Sending to these addresses is a red flag for inbox providers. Reduce the number of emails sent to invalid addresses by immediately removing bounced email addresses from your active mailing address.
It’s okay to buy, rent, or scrape email addresses, as long as you acknowledge your actions in the email footer.
Nope. It’s never okay to buy, rent, or scrap email addresses. Simple as that.
Recipient engagement is the most important factor in your sending reputation.
It doesn’t matter how professional your email looks if it’s getting poor opens, clicks, and spam complaints. Inbox providers want to provide their users with wanted mail, and these signals indicate if your messages are wanted or not.
How to Maintain Your Reputation and Keep Your Recipients Happy
Now that we’ve covered all of the different factors inbox providers take into account when evaluating your emails, it’s time to look at the messages you’re sending.
The actual messages you’re sending have a big impact on your deliverability and the ways that recipients engage with them.
Ask Permission and Respect It
Unlike other forms of marketing and advertising, email recipients have the choice of whether or not they open or even receive email communication. You are truly a guest in a recipient’s inbox. If you aren’t a polite and respectful guest (or if you wear out your welcome), you’ll get kicked out.
Be a Polite Guest
Be a polite guest in the inbox by asking for permission to send email, and then honoring the terms of that permission. If a recipient agrees to receive your weekly newsletter, you’re asking for trouble if you start to send them daily offers.
Create an Email Preference Center
This goes hand-in-hand with being a welcome guest in your recipient’s inbox. An email preference center allows users to tell you exactly what types of email they’re interested in. The key to a healthy email program is sending emails that people are interested in receiving. Take out the guesswork by asking your recipients exactly what they want and how often they want it.
Know Your Audience
We found that recipients (young and old) across the world have different email preferences. What works in one country might not work in another, and what works with gen z likely won’t work with the baby boomers.
Send a Welcome Message
A well-written welcome message helps set the tone for a new email relationship. Welcome messages should remind users why they signed up for your email program. This message should arrive as close to real-time as possible and detail what kinds of email the recipient can expect to receive from you and how often they’ll receive it. Welcome messages should also include unsubscribe and preference center links.
This welcome message from New York Times Cooking is a great example of a welcome message. It thanks the recipient for signing up and directs them to a few articles that may interest them. Toward the bottom of the message, they include a note that this is the first email in a series of 4, so expectations are clear from the beginning.
Stop Worrying About Gmail Tabs!
Gmail’s promotions tab is a third option outside of the typical “inbox” and “spam.” the promotions tab is not a commercial/promotional purgatory where messages are sent to float infinitely through the digital abyss. Email in the promotions tab is still regularly engaged with and checked.
Test Before You Send
Before you send any emails, it’s important to test your messaging and content to know how it will perform and how it gets to the inbox. Even little mistakes like broken links can lead to a decline in your deliverability in the long run, so testing your content before you send is really important.
Bundled messages in Gmail Promotions!
Google has been working to improve the promotions tab for both marketers and subscribers alike. Recently, senders have had the ability to add “annotations” to promotional messages. Gmail, in conjunction with their machine learning, uses these annotations to provide recipients with “bundles” of messages most relevant to their interests at the top of the promotions tab:
If you’re a Gmail user, these bundles are likely already in your promotions tab. The annotations appear in message headers and highlight helpful information including deal amounts and expiration times.
Remove Unengaged Recipients
Sending emails to recipients who no longer engage with your messages damages your sender reputation for several reasons:
- Addresses that don’t open or click on your messages are more likely to mark your messages as spam.
- Unengaged addresses can become spam traps.
- Unengaged recipients can lower your open rates, which makes your messages and traffic look unwanted.
B2B and B2C emails have a lot in common, but there are a couple of B2B distinctions you should keep in mind. Businesses come and go, and that often means the emails associated with that business become non-existent. You’ll need to keep up with your sunsetting policies to make sure you’re not sending messages to business email addresses that either no longer exist or are no longer in use.
Make It Easy to Unsubscribe
Although it may sound counterintuitive, making your unsubscribe process as simple and clear as possible improves the recipients’ experience and can be good for your sender’s reputation. If a recipient no longer wants or needs to receive your emails and there isn’t an easy way to unsubscribe, they are very likely to report your content as spam or junk. Remember, someone who opts out can always opt back in, but a spam complaint can be detrimental to your entire campaign as well as your email deliverability moving forward.
List-unsubscribe is an optional email header that allows recipients to remove themselves from a mailing list without clicking through an unsubscribe link or reporting a sender as spam or junk. If you implement list-unsubscribe, the major inbox providers will add unsubscribe links into the headers of your emails, which will allow recipients to unsubscribe without opening the message.
Allow Recipients to “Down Subscribe!”
Use your email preference center to your advantage by allowing recipients to “Down Subscribe,” aka allowing recipients to remove themselves from certain mailing lists or campaigns rather than removing themselves completely by unsubscribing.
Welcome messages should arrive in a new recipient’s inbox any time after opt-in.
Welcome messages should actually arrive as close to real-time as possible and include information about sending frequency as well as provide access to unsubscribe links and preference centers.
Every recipient wants to receive the same amount of email.
Every recipient has unique expectations for sending frequency, and if you exceed those expectations, they may unsubscribe or mark your messages as spam. In the 2019 Email Benchmark and Engagement Study, 54% of participants indicated that if companies sent them daily emails, it would weigh heavily into their decision to unsubscribe from that mailing list.
You should always test your emails before you actually press send.
Well done! It’s important to test your emails before sending them so that you know how they will perform. Even little mistakes like broken links can have an impact on your deliverability, so testing your content ahead of time can prevent some of these issues altogether.
Providing clear access to unsubscribe links is bad for your sending reputation.
Although it may seem counterintuitive, providing a simple and clear unsubscribe process can be good for your sending reputation. If recipients have access to an unsubscribe link or preference center, they are less likely to report your content as spam or junk – which is better for you in the long run.
Every email address you receive should stay on your mailing list forever.
Recipients that do not engage with your emails can be dangerous for your sending reputation for many reasons. Removing unengaged recipients can prevent unnecessary spam complaints, spam traps, and disproportionately low open rates.
“I probably sound like a broken record on a lot of client calls, but a common theme among clients with deliverability issues is their sunsetting policy… or lack thereof. I’ve seen companies sending their email campaigns to people who haven’t engaged in an email in YEARS!
Not only is this bad practice, but it’s also costing them money to store those old, unengaged email addresses. Get rid of them. If you have recipients who haven’t opened an email of yours in the last 30 days, it’s time to start saying goodbye. Slow down how often you send to them, and remove them if they still haven’t opened anything in 3 months.”
Hyperfocus on User Experience in 2021
Recipient engagement is one of the most critical signals impacting your sender’s reputation. Yes, infrastructure and authentication are important—however, top-notch wanted emails get engaged with, and engaging emails get delivered.
Email that customers love makes it to the inbox—simple as that.
The inbox environment is evolving, and brands that evolve with it to prioritize the user experience will see more engagement, improved reputation, and greater deliverability. Here are a few things you’ll need to focus on in 2021 to enhance your users’ inbox experiences.
Find Out What Your Users Want with A/B Testing
Thoughtful A/B testing ensures you’re listening to your recipients and continuously improving your email campaigns. A/B testing helps you dial in your user preferences by changing one element at a time to find what your customers like best.
Do more of your users engage with a text-only email? Drop the images from your campaigns and deliver them on the copy.
Do your customers open more of your messages on Tuesday or Friday? Strategize your campaigns to send when your users are most likely to engage.
A/B testing isn’t used just to boost open rates or click-through rates—it’s used to identify exactly what your users want so you can craft better email campaigns.
Keep It Simple
Get the small things right. The logo in your email should be hyperlinked to your website, and every message should have a clear, direct purpose.
Identify your email’s call-to-action (CTA). This is the purpose of your email. Why did you send it? What do you want your recipients to do?
Do you want them to answer a survey, make a purchase, or read an article? Make that clear with a singular, obvious CTA that tells your recipients exactly what to do:
- Contact Us
Your recipients should know the purpose of every email—make it clear and obvious.
Understanding Your Sending Metrics
As emails are sent and recipients interact with them, events are triggered. Having insight into how your emails are processed and engaged with is key to having a healthy and successful email program.
9 Primary Events of Email
- Processed: System has received your message and it’s ready to be delivered.
- Dropped: Some emails will be dropped (meaning not delivered) due to spam content, unsubscribe email addresses, bounced addresses, and more.
- Deferred: Email can’t always be delivered immediately. When it can’t, the email is deferred (often called a soft bounce)—we’ll continue trying to send your message for up to 72 hours. After that, the deferral turns into a block.
- Bounce: If a server doesn’t deliver your message, you’ll see a bounce. A bounce will help you know if you have invalid or outdated email addresses.
- Delivered: Your message has been successfully delivered to the receiving server. That doesn’t mean it’s landed in the inbox, though—it could have ended up in the spam folder.
- Open: Your recipient has opened your email message.
- Click: Your recipient has clicked on a link within the message.
- Spam Report: Your recipient has marked the email as spam.
- Unsubscribe: Your recipient has clicked the link to unsubscribe from your mailings.
Personalize Emails with Segment
Segment empowers you to collect, harness, and utilize engagement data to create better customer experiences. With segment, you can understand how your users interact with emails so that you can optimize your future campaigns to deliver the right message, to the right person, at the right time, on the right channel.
Mobile and Desktop Responsive
Now more than ever, your emails must be accessible on any device. According to the 2020 Global Messaging Engagement Report, 21% of US respondents read emails almost exclusively on their phones. This means that all of your content must be responsive and adapt to different device displays. That being said, recipients do still switch between computers and devices when checking their emails, with some users reporting a preference to click through links on a computer.
So, how do you handle these adaptation needs?
We recommend responsive templates. Responsive templates allow you to create emails that adapt to the unique needs of devices while maintaining great visual quality and consistency, no matter where an email is viewed.
Dark Mode is a color scheme that uses light-colored text and icons on top of a dark background. The darker design decreases the light emitted by screens while maintaining the contrasting colors necessary for readability. This saves the device’s energy, relieves eye strain, and can reduce screen glare.
Recently, Dark Mode has made its way into just about every app, browser, and device—and the inbox is no exception. In 2019, iOS Mail, Gmail, Outlook, and others announced support for Dark Mode. With so many users opting to use Dark Mode, it’s critical your emails still look great in this new environment.
Optimize for Dark Mode
Each inbox provider renders your html emails differently, but there are a couple of general best practices you can follow to make sure your email looks great regardless of the color scheme. First, enable dark mode in your email’s html and css. Second, optimize your transparent logos and images to look good with both light and dark color schemes—this is especially important if your png contains black text.
According to the last census, 56.7 million Americans (18.7% of the US population) have a disability. These disabilities range from hearing and vision impairment to loss of motor control. Imagine now that nearly 20% of your email list has some type of disability that makes engaging with your digital content a different experience. To improve the user experience for all your recipients, you need to create emails accessible to everyone.
Mozilla’s MDN defines accessibility as “the practice of making your websites usable by as many people as possible.” That doesn’t just limit catering to disabilities, either—that includes those with slower internet speeds, lower-quality devices, and other barriers. Better accessibility means better engagement, and better engagement leads to fewer unsubscribes and spam complaints.
Comply with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG)
Accessibility isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s a need-to-have. While there’s no single paramount law to make your digital content accessible, the W3C sets forth modern-day best practices in their WCAG guide.
However, some industries must follow certain guidelines to make content accessible by all (finance, government, etc.). Make sure you review the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to ensure your digital content is compliant.
Deliver on Promises
Another way to improve engagement and reduce spam complaints is to deliver on your email promises. While technically legal, certain grey-hat marketing practices (like gimmicky subject lines) can spoil your recipient’s inbox experience. Here are a few best practices to help you deliver on your inbox promises:
- Ensure your subject line and email content match: While clever, cutesy subject lines might get more clicks, try to avoid clickbait. Your subject line should be relevant to the content in your email. If not, recipients can quickly send you to the spam folder.
- Send what you said you’d send: When a subscriber enters their email address to signup for your blog’s weekly digest, that doesn’t automatically permit you to start blasting them with product announcements and sales. Only send the email you promised to send—nothing more, nothing less.
- Honor your unsubscribes: When a recipient unsubscribes from your emails, remove them from your mailing list as quickly as possible. Failing to do so is a surefire way to earn yourself a spam complaint.
“Always deliver on that subject line promise quickly and easily. Don’t make [recipients] hunt around and try to interpret what you were alluding to in the subject line.” – Jill Guest, Manager of Customer Marketing Holiday Email: What to Know Before You Send
Recipients know exactly what they want from senders and will unsubscribe or report emails as spam if they are feeling communications fatigue.
We define communications fatigue (or more specifically, email fatigue) as the feeling senders get when they receive more emails than they want from a sender. This could happen for a variety of reasons; the recipient could have a change in interest, there could be a lack of access to an email preference center, or even a change in your sending frequency.
Based on research, recipients are much more likely to forgive their favorite senders for sending multiple or repetitive emails, simply because they like their content. So long as they are interested in your product, service, or content, they may be interested in higher rates of communication.
As a sender, you’ll need to identify these high-volume recipients and determine how frequently they want to receive emails (once a day, once a week, etc.).
Often, however, these high-volume recipients are not the norm. For many recipients, receiving plenty of emails over a short period of time can be a turnoff and lead to the deletion or unsubscribes.
The study found that most recipients prefer to receive promotional emails once a week rather than daily. The small exception to this rule is limited offer deals.
You’ll also need to keep in mind your business’s collective communications with each recipient. While you may only send a recipient a few emails a week, keep in mind they may also be receiving SMS, display ads, LinkedIn InMails, and more from your brand. Too much contact on too many channels begins to feel like an invasion of privacy and a bit spammy—so make sure you approach your email with a holistic view.
“To a great extent, email deliverability is self-fulfilling. If you send content that your audience wants to receive and that they find interesting, the algorithms will learn that your email should be delivered to the inbox.
If you send email that wasn’t asked for and doesn’t deliver value, your recipients will act in a passive, or negative way and the algorithms that control filtering will learn to deliver your email to the junk folder. Of course, there are other influencing factors that contribute to email success, but ultimately, if you send email that people love, it will be successful.”
Infrastructure and Authentication
Infrastructure often refers to the IP addresses and servers you’re using to send an email, while authentication refers to the validation techniques you use to show that email coming from you is in fact yours. Your email infrastructure is what goes on behind the scenes to ensure your messages get to your recipient’s inbox.
Properly configuring your infrastructure can make or break your email deliverability. We’ll walk you through the basics below to get you up and running.
Dedicated IP Address
All email is delivered over an IP address. Inbox providers use your IP address to judge your sending reputation when determining whether or not to deliver your email to the recipient’s inbox.
If you’re a high-volume sender who wants to make sure you’re in complete control of your sending reputation, you’re going to need a dedicated IP address (or even a few addresses if you’re segmenting your email streams by type of email). Here’s why:
- If you’re sharing an IP address with other senders, their poor sending practices could impact your deliverability.
- With your own dedicated IP address, you’re in full control of your sending reputation and the impact it makes on your deliverability.
- If you send over 100k emails per year, a consistent sending pattern could help you build a solid reputation on a dedicated IP address. You’ll also be able to take advantage of other services for improved email deliverability.
Sharing an IP address can be a great solution, especially if you’re a low-volume sender sending less than 100k emails per year. In fact, if you’re fortunate to end up with a cohort of senders following email best practices, you could reap the rewards of a reputable IP address.
Experiment With Segmentation
Effectively segmenting your emails could improve your engagement, and improved engagement will lead to higher deliverability rates. Try segmenting your emails based on timezone, engagement level, sign-up date, purchase history, or age. Segmentation can help you cater to the needs of various types of recipients.
If you’re sending email over a new IP address, you’ll need to properly warm up your IP to ensure inbox providers deliver your emails.
Warm-up an IP address by sending low volumes of email on your new dedicated IP and then slowly increasing the volume over time. This provides Internet Service Providers (ISPs) time to recognize, identify, and evaluate your sending practices to make sure you’re a legitimate sender.
IP warmup is used to ramp up your sending volume to your predicted “normal” levels. This will help ISPs understand your usual sending volumes so they can identify unusual or dangerous behavior.
Email Stream IP Segmentation
Sharing a root domain across email streams (transactional vs. marketing) will combine reputations into each other. This can lead to deliverability issues if one of your streams is receiving more spam complaints or less engagement. To avoid potentially damaging your transactional email delivery, segment your different email streams onto multiple IP addresses.
For example, you may want to send all your transactional emails (password resets, confirmations, notifications, etc.) on one IP address and all your marketing emails (newsletters, promotions, product announcements) on another IP address. This way, if your marketing emails are flagged as spam, you won’t encounter deliverability issues on your essential transactional mail.
The most basic separation is at the level of marketing and transactional messages. These mail streams often have very different reputations and must comply with CAN-SPAM differently. For companies with multiple brands, it may be wise to separate the traffic by IP for each brand, and then further separate the marketing and transactional mail streams under each brand to provide granular reporting and reputation management.
Win-Back on a Different IP
According to postmasters we’ve spoken with, win-back (or reactivation) campaigns often have the poorest deliverability and highest spam complaints of any mainstream. Consider an ongoing drip campaign of reactivation emails (just a few hundred at a time) instead of a large one-time reactivation campaign to keep the volume of complaints low. You might also consider using a different IP so that you don’t potentially damage your primary IP/domain.
SPF Record Creation
SPF stands for Sender Policy Framework. SPF is an email authentication method that identifies the mail servers that are approved to send emails from a specific domain. ISPs use this validation protocol to determine when spammers and phishers are trying to impersonate your brand to send malicious emails from your domain.
DKIM Email Signature
DKIM stands for DomainKeys Identified Mail. DKIM allows you to publish a key that ISPs use to verify that the email message didn’t change in transit and the sender can take ownership of the content. DKIM defends against malicious modification of messages in transit, and it carries a lot of reputation weight with inbox providers.
DMARC Record Publishing
A Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance (DMARC) record is a protocol that uses SPF and DKIM to determine the authenticity of an email. The protocol allows you to specify how you want ISPs to handle emails that were not authenticated using SPF or DKIM.
Brand Indicators for Message Identification (BIMI)
BIMI is the newest way for you to verify your brand in the inbox. Similar to SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, BIMI is a TXT DNS Record that lives on your servers. BIMI provides another layer of trust and protection by adding your brand’s logo next to your emails.
A Records and rDNS
Records point your domain to an IP address, while rDNS (reverse DNS) links an IP to your domain. Having these pieces in place is an important step in building trust between you and inbox providers.
Your sending domain needs to be able to receive the email, and it must have a valid mail exchanger (MX) record. If not, some inbox providers will block your email.
TLS (Transport Layer Security)
TLS encrypts email while it’s being delivered. This prevents someone from reading the mail traffic as it moves between the sending and receiving servers. TLS has become a widely adopted security protocol to protect sensitive information and communications over email channels.
Spam feedback loops (FBLs) are offered by most mailbox providers to let you know when recipients mark messages as spam. Immediately remove the addresses of spam reporters from your active email lists to maintain your sending reputation and the respect of your audience.
“postmaster” and “abuse” Mailboxes
To access FBLs, many inbox providers require that you have abuse@ and postmaster@ email addresses. Monitor these mailboxes for complaints from inbox providers that don’t have FBLs so you can address any reports of unsolicited emails.
Two-Factor Authentication (2FA)
2FA is another layer of security protection you can add to your email account. If malicious users get access to your account, their fraudulent activity will very likely damage your sending reputation, even if you can recover from the hack.
“To be honest with you, switching IP addresses is almost never the answer to your email deliverability problems. Switching IPs when you’re having deliverability problems isn’t fixing any of the underlying problems. If you get a new IP, but maintain poor sending practices, you’ll continue to have email deliverability issues.
Switching IPs, but continuing to send similar content from an existing domain is a tactic used by spammers and malicious senders. Inbox providers will see this and may block your messages at the gateway.”
Privacy & Compliance in a World of Engagement
From Canadian Anti-Spam Legislation to the GDPR, global privacy trends are consistently moving to provide recipients with more and more control over how their data is used and the types of communication they prefer to receive.
In a global marketplace, most senders should be compliant with the strictest legislation that impacts their sending. For example, if you’re sending an email to recipients in the European Union, it’s best to make sure that all of your practices are compliant with the GDPR.
Compliance, however, isn’t only about doing what’s required. In fact, compliance with these new privacy laws will almost always help senders receive better results for their marketing efforts. When you set clear expectations about how a recipient’s data will be used, and the types of communications they should expect from a sender at the point of address collection, those recipients tend to be much more engaged with the email they receive. Engaged recipients (who aren’t reporting messages as spam) are what inbox providers look to for guidance when deciding which messages to deliver to the inbox and which ones to block at the gateway.
Think of user permissions and legal compliance requirements as an opportunity. Frame your approach to compliance with the recipient’s experience, and you may have more success getting your emails into the inbox.
In 2003, the United States Congress passed the Controlling the Assault of Non-Solicited Pornography and Marketing Act of 2003 or the CAN-SPAM Act. CAN-SPAM slowed the influx of unsolicited emails the world saw in the early 2000s by creating restrictions on the way commercial emails are sent and giving recipients privacy and protection. CAN-SPAM remains in effect today.
The FTC defines commercial email as any “electronic mail message the… purpose of which is the commercial advertisement or promotion of a… product or service.” If your business sends commercial emails of any kind, CAN-SPAM and its legal requirements of commercial entities should be on your radar.
Under the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003, all businesses using email for commercial purposes must comply with these 7 elements:
- Do not use misleading or false information in email headers
- Do not use deceptive language in email subjects
- Clearly and conspicuously identify advertising messaging as such
- Inform recipients of your business’s location
- Tell recipients how to opt-out of future communications
- Respect opt-out requests and handle them quickly
- Be cognizant of what third parties or others do on your business’s behalf
The biggest things to remember with CAN-SPAM are avoiding deception, clearly communicating the purpose of your email(s), and ensuring that recipients’ preferences are respected. More likely than not, you are already compliant with these elements. Remember, you must be compliant with the CAN-SPAM Act at all times if you send commercial emails.
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is one of the most hot-button topics related to email in the last decade. If your business works within the European Union or with its citizens, the GDPR should be top of mind when developing your international email strategy.
The GDPR updated and replaced the EU Data Protection Directive (1995) and applies to the entirety of the European Union as the de facto standard defining how companies can use customer data.
GDPR outlines 7 principles relating to the processing of personal data:
- Lawfulness, fairness, and transparency
- Purpose limitation
- Data minimization
- Storage limitation
- Integrity and confidentiality (security)
Under this law, EU citizens have more say over the ways organizations use their data. For those doing business in the United Kingdom, the GDPR is still in effect despite the UK’s exit from the EU.
The GDPR applies to all EU businesses, regardless of size or industry, that handle personal data, as well as any organization doing business in the EU where EU citizens’ data is involved.
GDPR compliance dominated conversations in the email world when it was put into effect. The importance of user privacy and compliance with international legislation is part of a larger, ongoing conversation that continues to evolve and adapt.
California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
The California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) became enforceable by the California Attorney General on July 1, 2020. The CCPA grants consumers considerably more control over their data and how it is used but only applies to businesses within specific categories.
Under the CCPA, consumers have the right to:
- Know “what personal information is collected, used, shared or sold” by organizations they interact with
- Delete “personal information held by businesses” which includes any of the business’s service providers
- Opt-out of the sale of their information
- Consumers have the right to “direct a business that sells personal information to stop selling that information”
- There are specific protections for minors as well:
- Those under age 16 “must provide opt-in consent”
- Those under age 13 must-have “parent or guardian consent” on their behalf
- Non-discrimination when exercising CCPA privacy rights, including access to “price or service”
Knowing this, here are the characteristics of businesses affected by the CCPA. Only one of the following needs to apply for your business to be affected.
Under the CCPA, businesses must comply if:
- The business’s gross annual revenue exceeds $25 million
- The business “buys, receives, or sells the personal information of 50,000 or more consumers, households, or devices”
- 50 percent or more of the business’s annual revenue comes from the sale of personal consumer information
Under new CCPA regulations, affected businesses must notify affected parties about data collection before or at the time of collection. Businesses must continue to comply with CAN-SPAM opt-out expectations in a timely and respectful manner, and also need to include a “Do Not Sell My Info” option to comply with the CCPA. Additionally, businesses must respond to opt-out requests or privacy setting changes, which can be fulfilled with a confirmation email.
Please note that compliance with CAN-SPAM and the GDPR do not ensure compliance with the CCPA. There are subtleties unique to each law that do not always overlap, so be sure to know how each law affects your strategy.
Country-Specific Email Regulations
From the California Consumer Protection Act to the GDPR, global privacy trends are consistently moving to provide recipients with more and more control over how their data is used and the types of communication they prefer to receive.
Compliance with one regulation does not ensure compliance with another. While some new privacy regulations share similar protections for recipients, their individual legal obligations do not necessarily overlap. Please be sure to do your research about laws in each country you plan to send to and know what your obligations are to remain compliant.
SMS: A Complementary Channel of Communication
What Is SMS?
SMS stands for “short messaging service,” also known as a text message. SMS is a simple, but powerful, communication tool businesses and organizations can use to send promotional or informational messages via text.
SMS messages, or text messages, have unmatched open rates, allowing businesses to communicate with their customers in a quick, reliable way.
Like email, SMS messages are delivered in seconds. Text messages can initiate two-way conversations and are easy to track. By using SMS in addition to email, you can provide your customers with an integrated and seamless communication experience. Plus, you’re giving them the option to connect and communicate on the channels they prefer.
Over 5.2 billion people have access to SMS, including many people who lack a smartphone or broadband internet. While SMS is the most widely used application in the world, businesses today face challenges with implementing and scaling their SMS delivery programs. SMS deliverability measures the percentage of outgoing SMS messages that are received at their intended destination. SMS deliverability is critical for businesses that want to reach their audience through relevant, personalized, and timely messaging.
Whether you send a text message from a mobile device or an SMS API, there is a percentage of SMS messages that will never be delivered. As opposed to thumbing out a text on a phone, SMS messages sent programmatically through an SMS Gateway have an advantage—application logic can verify delivery.
There are many places where SMS delivery might fail, especially as messages move through the interfaces between pieces of infrastructure. Common causes of message delivery failure include invalid phone numbers, end-device level errors (like a handset being turned off), or problems with network connectivity. Other deliverability issues are deliberate, and messages reported by users may be blocked by carrier partners.
It’s important to comply with state or local regulations and wireless carriers’ messaging policies to ensure SMS deliverability for both transactional and marketing messages. Wireless carriers have filtering systems to protect mobile subscribers from unwanted spam, fraud, or abuse. Filtering can range from a simple list of prohibited terms to advanced machine learning systems that adapt based on the messages passing through them.
To reduce the risk of your messages being filtered or facing deliverability issues, businesses should follow these best practices for SMS messaging:
- Get permission: Only send text messages to customers who have permitted you to do so. Request that your users opt-in to your SMS messaging via an online form or by asking them to text a particular keyword to a mobile number or shortcode.
- Check your list: Ensure the phone numbers on your list are correct and can receive text messages. Invalid numbers (like landlines) are the most common reason for message delivery problems, and changed (or fake) phone numbers won’t reach their intended destination, decreasing your message delivery.
- Don’t be spammy: Include clear opt-out instructions, precise language, and proper capitalization and punctuation in your messaging. Message your customers with relevant, time-sensitive promotions or information.
- Use the right phone number: You can use either toll-free numbers or shortcodes—both support higher sending volumes and reduced filtering. Shortcodes are 5 or 6 digit phone numbers specifically made for mass mobile communications. Shortcodes are individually approved by wireless carriers so they won’t get blocked and can send at a faster rate than regular mobile numbers. Consider using a unique, brand-friendly shortcode for mass SMS messages. However, toll-free numbers and shortcodes aren’t available in every country.
- Choose carefully: Choose an SMS provider that will provide helpful error code reporting and status callbacks so your business can diagnose any deliverability issues.
SMS is a universal communication channel that is meant to enhance, not replace, an existing email program. Just like email, SMS messaging should aim to keep recipients happy with valuable, relevant, and personalized information on the channels they prefer.
Email or SMS: Which Channel Should I Use?
SMS and email are complementary channels that can be used to create a seamless customer communication experience. You can use text messaging for short, time-sensitive communications; this means everything from appointment reminders to last-minute sale alerts. Use email to send more content and information to the place your customers are already going to every day: the inbox.
Case Study: Yelp
Using SMS, Yelp meets its user base where they’re active: on mobile devices. Yelp customers can text their favorite restaurants to make, modify, or cancel their reservations. Businesses can easily update their customers on wait times, reservation availability, and reply to their texts straight from Yelp Reservations.
Though not yet regulated to the same extent as email, SMS sending practices have their own legal obligations. Generally, you’ll need consent to send marketing or commercial communications via SMS. SMS privacy regulations beyond this vary by country, so please be sure to do your research on maintaining compliance everywhere you plan to send.
Email Deliverability Tools
We’ve mentioned a lot of helpful tools throughout this guide, but you don’t need to read through it all again to find them.
Below, we’ve listed and linked to the top email deliverability tools:
- Google Postmaster Tools: Track data on large volumes of emails sent and find data about your sending domain.
- ValiMail: Improve your deliverability and protect your brand, customers, partners, and employees with automated DMARC / DKIM / SPF.
- Talos IP & Domain Reputation Center: Get real-time alerts on network and software vulnerabilities worldwide.
- MXToolbox Blacklist Check: Check to see if your mail server has been blacklisted.
- Microsoft’s Smart Network Data Services (SNDS): Track your sender’s reputation and activity across the Microsoft network.
- SenderScore.org: Gauge your Sender Score just like you’d check your creditworthiness.
Email delivery is an ever-evolving part of your program. As inbox providers’ preferences change, new rules and regulations get implemented, and new features become available, you have to continually adapt to keep your deliverability in tip-top shape. While there’s no magic bullet that’s going to get all of your emails to the inbox, we believe that nearly every piece of advice in this guide can be boiled down to a single principle:
Send the right message, to the right person, at the right time, with the right frequency, on the right channel.
As a sender, you should be attempting to accomplish this with the following process:
The right message: Send the types of messages your recipients are expecting to receive with the content they want.
- The right person: Send emails to people who have explicitly asked to receive them.
- The right time: Send messages when your recipients are expecting to receive them.
- The right frequency: Don’t spend too much email to your recipients or email them too frequently.
- The right channel: Send on the channels appropriate to the message and audience.
Source from TWILIO SendGrid